For 45 years, we’ve built our reputation on honest feedback—even when it’s difficult to hear. We believe candor serves writers best, so we’ll always tell you the truth about your manuscript’s potential. If we think further work with us won’t benefit you, we’ll say so. If your publishing goals don’t align with your manuscript’s current state, we’ll explain why.
Our commitment is to constructive honesty. While we approach every manuscript looking for its strengths and possibilities, we won’t mislead you about serious challenges or unrealistic expectations.
Want to understand our approach better? Read our article: The First Duty of a Manuscript Critique: What to expect when your manuscript has serious problems—and why candor serves writers best.